COPPHA Peer Review Proforma

This proforma is designed for use in open peer review of journal and other scholarly submissions. It provides a structured set of questions to guide reviewers in assessing scientific articles as well as other types of submissions, including editorials, reports, policy documents, and presentations. The proforma covers aspects such as structure, content, methodological rigor, transparency, and language. It supports open and transparent peer review and aligns with good practices in critical appraisal and research integrity.